Home » Guides » How to Keep Alfredo Sauce Creamy

How to Keep Alfredo Sauce Creamy

The main feature of a quality alfredo sauce is how creamy it is, you would want to take a bite of the sauce coating your preferred pasta and taste the goodness of yummy butter and cheese rather than a grainy mixture that doesn’t feel good to eat.

So, when making your alfredo sauce, it is advisable to take the actions that would keep your alfredo sauce tasty and creamy for a long period. The tips and tricks to do this would save you a lot of stress and would make your alfredo dish one to remember – for all the good reasons.

What Makes Alfredo Sauce Creamy?

What makes an alfredo sauce creamy lies in the recipe that is used in its preparation. A recipe that has butter, cream cheese, heavy cream, and freshly grated parmesan cheese is often recommended for a creamy alfredo sauce. This sauce should be whisked properly over low to medium heat so that the components of the sauce do not separate before you’re able to use it.

How to Keep Alfredo Sauce Creamy?

To keep the alfredo sauce creamy, prepare it with freshly grated parmesan cheese rather than the already prepared one bought at the store, an option is to buy a lump of parmesan from the grocery store and grate it yourself thinly. Heavy cream is also recommended for use, it is added to the butter and cheese mixture to give the alfredo sauce a smooth and velvety consistency.

Another method used, especially when you’re making a pasta dish is to add a little of the water used to prepare the pasta to the meal and stir it properly, this will ensure that the alfredo sauce coats the pasta evenly and would help retain its texture.

How Do You Keep Alfredo Sauce from Drying Out?

To keep your alfredo sauce from drying out and the pasta absorbing the sauce, wash the pasta with cold water after it is done cooking, then add some olive oil to it, tossing it properly so that the oil can mix with the pasta well. This should be done before you add the alfredo sauce. The cold water lowers the temperature of the cooked pasta and the olive oil acts as a barrier between the alfredo sauce and the pasta, they both work to keep the alfredo sauce from drying out.

How Do You Make Alfredo Sauce Creamy Again?

When you have leftover alfredo sauce, it is sometimes an issue to get it creamy again and back to its original texture. One way to make the Alfredo sauce creamy again is by heating it in a saucepan over a stove in medium to low heat, while doing that, whisk the sauce to ensure that the elements of the mixture do not separate. If the sauce is too thick, you can add warm milk to the mixture to thin it out.

Why Is My Fettuccine Alfredo Not Creamy?

Your fettuccine alfredo not being creamy can be due to several reasons, first, it could be that the ingredients such as butter, cream cheese, and heavy cream (optional) were not whisked together properly under medium heat and so they separate later. Fettucine alfredo that is not creamy could also be as a result of using store-bought parmesan cheese that is not grated well, and therefore, does not dissolve entirely, causing lumps in the pasta. It is often recommended to add the salted water used to boil the pasta over low heat to the mixture of pasta and alfredo sauce that is not creamy.

What Causes Grainy Alfredo Sauce?

What causes grainy alfredo sauce could be the use of low-quality ingredients to prepare the sauce. Most times, this happens when you use store-bought pre-shredded cheese, this kind of cheese already contains preservatives that would prevent it from melting totally, making your sauce grainy. Also, try to keep the sauce at a low to medium boil while preparing it, a large amount of heat can cause the cheese to change its texture. 

How To Make Alfredo Sauce With Milk And Parmesan

  • Ingredients include milk, parmesan cheese, wheat flour, butter, garlic, salt, and pepper. The steps to prepare this sauce follows the usual process, but without the addition of heavy cream.
  • Heating your pan over low heat and then adding butter to it, use a spoon to stir it in and ensure that the butter melts. Put in chopped garlic and allow to simmer.
  • Add your wheat flour and whisk with the butter and garlic mixture.
  • Pour milk and continue to whisk it slowly for an even mixture.
  • When you’ve added all the milk, put in your shredded parmesan cheese, allow to melt and stir it properly. Add salt and cayenne pepper for taste, and your alfredo sauce is ready.

Read also: 6 Best Pizza Stones with Handles and Racks

How To Make Creamy Alfredo Sauce From The Jar

Store-bought sauces are sometimes bland and need some work for them to be as creamy as the homemade sauce, here are a few things to remedy that and make you a delicious and creamy alfredo sauce from the jar.

To start with, the ingredients needed are garlic, butter, liquid chicken broth or milk, ¼ cup of finely grated parmesan cheese.

  • Put butter in a warm pan over medium heat and allow for it to melt.
  • Add diced cloves of garlic for flavor and sauté it for 3 minutes.
  • Pour the jar of alfredo sauce into the pan (pick a brand suitable to your taste)
  • Then add the parmesan cheese little by little, ensuring that it melts in the sauce completely. 
  • If the sauce is too thick, thin it out by adding milk or liquid chicken broth.
  • You can whisk the sauce to blend all the ingredients well and also switch things up by adding spices.

Read also: How to Cool Angel Food Cake Without Glass Bottle and Upside Down


Making your alfredo sauce creamy results in a tasty dish from start to finish. For the pasta used for this sauce, Food Network recommends fettuccine, pappardelle, and linguine as their shapes make it easy for the sauce to hold on to. However, Alfredo sauce is not limited to only pasta, it can serve as a topping for pizzas, slices of toast, etc. and to make it a balanced meal, a suggested protein accompaniment could be shredded chicken or a large serving of shrimp.