6 Best Pizza Stones for Traeger Grills

If you’re a pizza enthusiast and making pizzas in the comfort of your home works for you, a good pizza stone is a cup to your water.

A good pizza stone will not just sit well in your Traeger grill but will give your pizza a perfect crispy finish while making sure your pizza is well cooked and also retains the warmth. Who wouldn’t want that?

In a Hurry? Here’s Our Top Three

Bestseller No. 1
Nuwave Heavy-Duty Cordierite Pizza & Baking Stone, Heat Resistant up to 1472°F, Great for Indoor Electric Ovens, Outdoor Gas, Wood Fire Grills, BBQ Grilling, & NuWave Bravo XL, Fits Most Frozen Pizzas
  • PREMIUM QUALITY MATERIAL - The pizza stone is odorless and made from 100% all-natural FDA-safe durable Cordierite...
  • SUPERIOR HEAT RETENTION – The pizza stone is durable and heat-resistant up to 1472°F making it the perfect...
  • RESISTANT TO CRACKING – The pizza stone is developed and rigorously tested to withstand the shock of extreme heat...
Bestseller No. 2
4 PCS Rectangle Pizza Stone Set, 15" Large Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill with Pizza Peel(OAK), Pizza Cutter & 10pcs Cooking Paper for Free, Baking Stone for Pizza, Bread,BBQ
  • 4 PCS Pizza Stones set:The rectangle pizza stone measures 15" * 12" Come with OAK solid wood pizza paddle(12" X...
  • Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill :15 x 12 inch pizza baking stone made of all-natural FDA-safe Cordierite stone,which...
  • 12 inch pizza paddle: pizza peel made of precious oak .different from conventional bamboo or pinewood . Our wooden...
Bestseller No. 3
Unicook 16 Inch Round Pizza Baking Stone, Heavy Duty Cordierite Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill, Thermal Shock Resistant, Ideal for Baking Crisp Crust Pizza, Bread and More, Includes Scraper
  • 【Durable Construction】 Unicook pizza stone is made of all natural Cordierite, sintered in 2100°F kiln for...
  • 【Secret of Super Crisp Crust Pizza】Full of invisible micro-pores which draw out moisture from dough, distribute...
  • 【Multi-functional Pizza Stone】16 inch round pizza stone measures 16" by 16", golden thickness 0.65"(15mm),...

We made a quick list of the best pizza stones for Traeger grills. We reviewed these pizza stones as well, so you know what you should expect with your purchase!

Best pizza stones for Traeger grills

Invalid table id.

Cast Elegance Theramite Durable Pizza and Baking Stone

Cast Elegance Durable Thermal Shock Resistant Thermarite Pizza and Baking Stone for Oven and Grill, Includes Recipe E-Book & Cleaning Scraper, 16 inch Round, 5/8th inch Thick
  • Crispy Crust: Make restaurant-quality pizzas at home without the need of a bulky wood-fired or brick pizza oven....
  • Extreme Versatility: Clean with a damp cloth (no soap or water) when finished. Our Pizza Stones are odorless and...
  • Superior Durability and Heat Retention: Thermarite is durable, strong, and has superior thermal shock ability...

Cast Elegance Pizza Stone with Theramite offers a crispy crust and well-cooked pizza. Cast Elegance pizza stone seems to absorb dough moisture pretty impressively to give that yummy crispy crust.

But everything good has a downside. Cast Elegance Pizza Stone with theramite have been noted to sometimes break under heat, develop a stubborn toxic odor, and may develop a fungal infestation. There’s also a likelihood of having your pizza stuck to the stone, which sounds pretty annoying. 

Nevertheless, if you’re looking to try out this pizza stone, prepare yourself for an evenly cooked and well-crusted pizza. 

Outset 76176 Pizza Grill Stones

Transform your kitchen to an antiquated pizzeria for a night with these Outset 76176 Pizza Grill stones. These almost 6-pound baking stones cook the pizzas quickly but don’t exactly get the job done, parts of the pizza may still be uncooked. With this pizza stone, you may be at risk of an uncrusty pizza.

This pizza grill stone does not clean well if you get cheese on them. 

A good feature of this pizza stone is that it gives room for cooking. The tiles layout well in the oven and offers a larger cooking surface, although some believe that the tiles are still too small for their convenience.

Hans Grill Baking Stone for Pizzas (9.08 pounds in weight)

HANS GRILL PIZZA STONE | Circular Pizza Stone For Oven Baking & BBQ Grilling With Free Wooden Peel | Extra Large Round Round 15" Inches Diameter (38CM) Durable Cordierite Cooking Stone.
  • PIZZA STONES FOR GRILL AND OVEN | Our very best pizza stone formulated from toughened porous cordierite stone. FDA...
  • BAKING STONE | Multiple use set for baking Italian style pizza, pies, pastry, frozen pizza, calzone and artisan...
  • INDOOR OR OUTDOOR | The perfect stone pizza pan for oven and BBQ use. Dine al fresco under the stars or stay warm...

Cooks pizzas in a 10/10 style. Hans Grill Baking Stone for Pizzas seems to be doing things right. With this pizza stone, you get a well-done pizza and crispy crust. The Stone is thick, sturdy, and heats up impressively. Cleaning this pizza stone tends to be a walk in the park too. 

Regardless of all these interesting qualities, Hans Grill Baking Stone for Pizzas has a small peel that may not be so exciting if you want something bigger. Also, you need to check the size of your oven before getting this 17.4 x 16.93 x 2.44-inch pizza stone as size is usually a problem. Finally, if you detest pizza stones that get stained quickly, you should avoid this one.

Heritage Pizza Stone

Sale
Heritage 15" Ceramic Pizza Stone Set - Non-Stick, Stain-Free with Bonus Cutter - Black
  • Make great pizzas with no hassle: The ceramic pizza stone heats up faster than other materials which will allow you...
  • Crispiness on the menu: Both our round pizza stone and rectangle pizza stone make it easy to achieve those desired...
  • Minimize Mess: Our superior baking stone is grease and burn resistant, coated in a non-stick glaze that prevents...

Are you on the lookout for a premium pizza stone that is going to last?

If yes, this is your bus stop. Heritage Pizza Stone is a premium product that doesn’t just cook your pizza well but is also easy to clean, big enough for your grill. 

There may be one problem though, it could break in the long run from the consistent heat. 

Cuisinart CPS-445, 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set

Sale
Cuisinart CPS-445, 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set, Stainless Steel
  • ESSENTIAL PIZZA TOOLS: Set includes 13" Pizza Stone; Folding Pizza Peel and Pizza Cutter
  • PIZZA PEEL: Folding handle stainless pizza peel stores easily
  • PIZZA WHEEL: The pizza wheel cutter easily slices through pies for quick cutting

These pizza stones are inexpensive and come with a quality-made peel, which can sometimes be sticky, feel small, and flimsy a well. The stone has the potential to get sticky and to acquire a smell that may last over time and you may find unpleasant. 

Despite these, this pizza stone still does what it’s meant to by pre-heating fast. 

Hans Grill Baking Stone for Pizzas

HANS GRILL PIZZA STONE | Rectangular Pizza Stone For Oven Baking & BBQ Grilling With Free Wooden Peel | Extra Large 15 x 12" Inch Durable Cordierite Cooking Stone.
  • PIZZA STONES FOR GRILL AND OVEN | Our very best pizza stone formulated from toughened porous cordierite stone. FDA...
  • BAKING STONE | Multiple use set for baking Italian style pizza, pies, pastry, frozen pizza, calzone and artisan...
  • INDOOR OR OUTDOOR | The perfect stone pizza pan for oven and BBQ use. Dine al fresco under the stars or stay warm...

A pizza stone with no chemical odor that cooks pizzas relatively well and is non-stick is the ultimate pizza stone and this offers those qualities. 

Some users have reported this pizza stone to cause your pizza to get soggy sometimes or burn their pizza without cooking it well. Also, it comes with a manual that is not in English which can make things hard, and a pizza peel whose handle is quite short and can get you a burn on your knuckles if you’re not careful. 

If you love homemade pizza and you’re interested in making them yourself, getting the best pizza stones for Traeger grills will do you a whole lot of good in the long run.

By Luong Tan

Luong Tan, the creative and passionate founder of Bourbono, is a multi-talented individual with a deep love for the culinary arts. An accomplished food blogger, cookbook author, and former Ambassador of US cuisine in Vietnam (2015-2016), Luong has been on a mission to share his appreciation for food with the world.

Related Posts